Meet your local agents
We aren’t just agents, we’re family. That sets us apart. When you work with Integrity, we take the time to understand your needs. Our mission is to make insurance simple, approachable, and tailored just for you.
Al Derway
Al has proudly called Lake City home for over 30 years and began his career in insurance in 2007. With a genuine passion for helping others, he has built his expertise around guiding clients through the often-complex world of insurance—especially Medicare Supplement Plans. Al is deeply rooted in his faith, family, and core values, which shape the way he serves each client with care and integrity. Outside the office, he enjoys gaming, music, and cherishing time with his three beloved grandchildren.
Kat Derway
Kat has been immersed in the world of insurance since the age of 10, inspired by her father’s dedication to the field. Determined to follow in his footsteps, she earned her insurance license at just 18 years old and now specializes in Medicare Advantage Special Needs Plans. Kat also manages outreach and events as well as marketing for Integrity. Known affectionately as the “Chaos Coordinator” of the Derway household, she’s always ready to lend a helping hand with a smile.
Aidan Tolbert
Aidan relocated from Fort Myers to Lake City in 2022 to join Kat and Al in their family-centered insurance business. She specializes in Medicare Advantage and Affordable Care Act (ACA) insurance and is dedicated to helping clients find coverage that truly fits their needs. As Kat’s best friend and trusted teammate, Aidan brings a strong sense of collaboration and reliability to the office. Outside of work, she enjoys cooking, gaming, working on cars, and tackling hands-on projects around the house. She is also an avid Harry Potter fan.
Join the Integrity family —